XGman manual: key #60 should be C3 not C4

2 posts / 0 new
Last post
Greg Holwell
Greg Holwell's picture
XGman manual: key #60 should be C3 not C4

The parts screen shows that key #0 is C-2 and #127 is G8. By this reasoning #60 should be C3.

Mark van den Berg
Mark van den Berg's picture

At least four different systems for MIDI note names are in existence.

In nearly all places my applications use a system in which note #0 is called "C-1". For instance, this is what is shown on the statusbar of the "MIDI keyboard" window, which is incorporated in many of my applications.
The rationale for this choice (which I made decades ago) was that the Roland company uses this system, and that most of my applications (particularly back then) concerned Roland/BOSS devices.

However, Yamaha uses a system in which note #0 is called "C-2", which is why the Parts window of XG Manager uses that.

It will be hard to come up with a solution that is not confusing to some group of users, but I'll think about it. Perhaps users could be given a choice, with the default being the Yamaha system in XG Manager, and the Roland system in Roland/BOSS editors.
Anyway, thanks for pointing this out!